Saturday, February 13, 2010

Mixed Race and Out of Place

What is it like to be of mixed race? (And I don't mean way-back-in-my-family-history sort of mixed race, but mixed race as in one parent of one race, the other parent of another). No, it's not always easy. No, I am constantly "confused" about my identity (I know exactly what I am, it's how other people perceive it that is the problem). And yes, I do enjoy it despite everything.

There are two levels to my personal experiences: race as related to culture and lifestyle, and race as related to outward appearance.

Regarding race as related to culture and lifestyle, I feel out of place because each of my sides live their lives differently, neither of which exactly fit me. A lot of people don't understand when I say I feel like I don't fit in anywhere. I guess it is hard to understand unless you personally experience it or witness someone else experiencing it. It's kind of like straddling two worlds and wishing someone else had the same combination. In this sense, it's similar to immigrants coming to the United States, and having children growing up surrounded by the American way of life but also surrounded by a family that lives in a different way and has different beliefs. It's not unlike Anzaldua's "mestiza consciousness," where she straddles two worlds and so creates a third identity to reconcile them. If you hang out with one side, they're kind of like you in some sense, but not fully, and same with the other side. In my case, I can hang out with other Muslims because they also don't drink (which is something you don't always get on the other side), but I still don't quite fit in because I didn't grow up going to the mosque for Sunday school (only for a couple years) so sometimes people will talk about things that I have absolutely no clue about. And my lifestyle choices are not always the same because while the traditional thing to do is have an arranged marriage (though this isn't always the case anymore), it's something I definitely would never do. But on the other side, it's the same thing: in some ways you fit in, but in some ways you don't. But, this isn't always to do with race, it's just the culture that comes along with the race, so as I said earlier, this is something that is experienced by children of immigrants living in the US, and people of a certain religion that aren't as "religious" as others in the same religion. So, this point isn't necessarily about race exclusively.

But regarding race specifically, there are some challenges as well. It's frustrating when people label me as "white" just because I'm light-skinned. I mean I guess it's a fair assumption to make, especially from afar, but if you compare me to a true "white girl" there are significant differences, so it's not fair to label me as a person that I don't always have much in common with. People who do that have no idea who I really am, how I've been raised, and how I live my life. It's happened to me so much growing up that I internalized it. In my Race, Class, and Gender course 2 years ago, we had to write a Racial Identity Development paper in which we discussed our experiences of racialization throughout our lives. We first had to pick whether we identified ourselves as white or as a person of color. I immediately decided I was white (based on the white privileges I've had), but then thought twice after speaking with the professor and realizing I had experiences as a person of color also (since my name and facial features are often non-white indicators). So, after discussing this, I argued in my paper that I am sometimes white and sometimes a person of color, depending on the circumstance. This is not how I feel about myself (I just like to think I am ME), but rather how others have perceived me. Since the world doesn't do so well with these fuzzy in-between categories (we like to place people into categories, hence the black/white racial dichotomy) I am put to one category or another, but you can never be BOTH at once. (I mean hey, that's just asking for a little too much). It gets a little tiring when people try to tell you who you are. I remember when I was younger, some friends and I were all deciding which Disney princess we were most like. I thought that I was Belle from Beauty and the Beast (brown hair, light skin), but another girl told me I was Jasmine from Aladdin. Though she didn't state it blatantly, the underlying (subconscious) message she was sending was, "you're not white, you're brown." Um thank you, for explaining my identity to me.

When I was younger I always considered myself to be white. I don't know why, I felt more drawn to that side I suppose. It may possibly have something to do with internalizing how people perceived me, but I haven't explored that possibility fully just yet. But as I've gotten older I've tried (and struggled) to embrace both sides. As of now, I just consider myself to be ME (and my particular mix), rather than trying to say I identify with one side over the other (I really can't stand getting that question, it happens way too often).


  1. Nice elaboration of thoughts, while understanding the point is none other than confused personality. Now we should come immediately to the point that asks us “Why is it so?” The answer to many other questions is in this answer that says ‘Religion is indeed base of every other one’s lifestyle’ its not that being part of a multi social region of many different individuals from different parts of world or the dominating group due to which one should leave their reality. Coming towards the point of tradition there is only trend that religion follows is important one to go; As God loves us seventy times more than our real mothers, so there is no way He the Most Merciful One has some wrong plans for you and this series of question if you come to truth is for you to find your real identity. Prophet Mohammed Peace Be Upon Him & His Descendants said “Nothing is better than Nikkah between two loved ones” so this clearly indicates that this religion of God does not prohibits from any kind of marriage.
    I would like to conclude at end that all the races have found the peak of glory only by following their traits, and yours are the great ones leading to ultimate all realities. Always remember your religion is base that does not prohibits you other than from evils, I have many drinking colleagues they take wine and I go for my juice or soft drinks at the same time and same with other stuffs. So just follow your reality only, as one of my most respected teacher guided me stating “I like your individual style, please remain to ‘be yourself’ always”.

  2. I know this post is a little old, but I wanted to comment and thank you for sharing your experience. A while ago, I wrote a post on being <a HREF=">a white convert and how fellow Muslims and non-Muslims</a> stopped seeing my "whiteness" and just assumed me to be "other."

    Your post has given me some great insight into how my daughter may feel when she gets older. It's nice to know that despite your feelings of inclusion and exclusion, you've obviously reconciled to some degree and have turned out okay :) It's shows great strength of self to be able to say that you identify as simply, "me." Not a lot of people are so sure to be able to say that.

  3. Woodturtle: Sorry I am seeing this comment so late! Clearly I really need to get going with this blog :) Thanks for the reading and for the link, I'll be sure to check it out soon!